"Completely Voluntary:" Ubisoft Once Again in Hot Water Over Soliciting Fan Music for Watch Dogs: Legion

"Completely Voluntary:" Ubisoft Once Again in Hot Water Over Soliciting Fan Music for Watch Dogs: Legion

An old controversy heats up once again for Ubisoft.

Ubisoft has partnered with music hosting service HitRecord to let fans get songs into Watch Dogs: Legion. And, much like the last time this happened, it's drawn ire and criticism over soliciting voluntary spec work. Today, Ubisoft has responded to that criticism by standing its ground.

In a post to the Watch Dogs: Legion account, Ubisoft reiterated that they are already working with artists and composers for more than 140 licensed songs and an original score. But as for the HitRecord submissions, they just remind the reader that they are voluntary submissions, meant to offer a chance for their own song in the game.

Of the songs submitted to the competition, 10 will be chosen and admitted into Watch Dogs: Legion. The 10 artists will receive a community payment of $2000. This type of work is often called spec work, where a client wants a finished product before agreeing to pay for it.

As the AIGA puts it, those who create work on spec risk being taken advantage of. "Some clients may see this as a way to get free work; it also diminishes the true economic value of the contribution designers make toward client's objectives." Various developers, like Mike Bithell and Danny Baranowsky, as well as the LA chapter of Game Workers Unite, have spoken out against this contest.

This particular partnership, which would allow HitRecord community members the chance to get their song into the world of Watch Dogs: Legion, isn't even the first time Ubisoft has opened this can of worms. The publisher came under criticism for a similar partnership for Beyond Good & Evil 2. Maybe things will change before Watch Dogs: Legion's release date on March 6, 2020.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Eric Van Allen

News Editor

Eric is a writer and Texan. He's a former contributor to sites including Compete, Polygon, Waypoint, and the Washington Post. He loves competitive games, live music, and travel.

Read this next

"Eventually, All of Our Games Will Be Safely in the Cloud Too and We'll Feel Great About It"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Google responds to legitimate concerns about Stadia by talking to would-be customers like they are toddlers.

Watch Dogs Legion Release Date, Map, Gameplay - Everything We Know

This is our guide to the Watch Dogs Legion release date, map of London, gameplay reveal, and more.

The E3 2019 Awards: The Best Games We Saw at This Year's Show

Here are all the best games we saw at E3 2019, including our Game of the Show!

The Actual Winners and Losers of E3 2019

Tired: Ray-tracing, 8K graphics, and bombshell announcements. Wired: Pitbulls, pee scandals, and grannies who kill.

Watch Dogs Legion Chose London Before Brexit, But It's Still Ubisoft's Most Political Game to Date

We hands-on with the latest in the Watch Dog's franchise and interview Ubisoft's Clint Hocking.

More News

Ion Fury Developer Donates $10,000 to Charity After Furor Over Transphobic Comments

The studio is apologizing for comments both in and out of the game.

More on PC

Ion Fury Developer Donates $10,000 to Charity After Furor Over Transphobic Comments

The studio is apologizing for comments both in and out of the game.

Humankind is Amplitude Studios' Shot at Improving Civilization

After several excellent 4X titles, Amplitude is coming for Civilization directly.

MTG Arena Coming to Epic Games Store This Winter

There's another platform option for playing MTG Arena on PC.

Kerbal Space Program 2 Launching on Consoles in 2020

The lovable game about space exploration is finally getting a sequel.

Gears 5 Has a Crossover With Halo: Reach

And Horde mode is looking a little Overwatch-y.

More Action Adventure Games

Sony Acquires Ratchet and Clank, Spider-Man Dev Insomniac Games

The longtime partner of Sony's is jumping aboard.

Every Game and Trailer Shown off During the August Nintendo Indie World Showcase

Did you miss this morning's Indie World showcase? Let us help you.

Fire Emblem Three Houses Recruitment Students - All Recruiting Requirements for Students and Teachers

Here's our guide covering Fire Emblem Three Houses recruitment, including recruiting students, teachers, and more.