USgamer's Best of E3 2018 Award Winners and Community Pick

USgamer's Best of E3 2018 Award Winners and Community Pick

It's been another crazy E3. Here are our awards for the Best Games of E3 2018, including the Community Pick you all voted on.

Finally, we can rest. E3 2018 has concluded. We wrote, played, and worked a lot, all for the sake of video games. With the annual Electronic Entertainment Expo's conclusion, we're ready to name our official award winners. And yours too.

For this year's awards, we're following a similar formula to last year's. We have our Best Game of the Show (wherein the only requirement is that it was playable at some capacity), Best Non-Playable Game, Best Reveal (for celebrating a surprise announcement), and obviously our Community Pick for the Best Game of E3 2018, tallied from your comments. We'd like to also give a special thanks to everyone for following our coverage this week (there was a lot of it). And now, let's start off with a bang: the Best Game of E3 2018 is…

USgamer Best of E3 2018 Winner

Resident Evil 2

The Resident Evil 2 remake is a success. If the rest of the game is even half as successful as the 40 minute preview I played (and I have reason to believe it is) then Capcom might pull off a remaster that outdoes its legendary update of the first Resident Evil.

Resident Evil 2 isn't just an impressive remake, though—it's a reimagining that injects fresh horror into the classic original. I guarantee that even if you've played the original Resident Evil 2 on the PS1, you won't be prepared for what Capcom has in store for you with the remake. The new third-person perspective doesn't dilute the game's atmosphere, but rather enhances it thanks to how fluid and natural the game feels, which in turn makes the game more realistic. The realism naturally feeds into a new kind of horror experience.

With a new level of detail that adds depth (you can shoot off a zombie's limbs), a third-person perspective, combat that finally outdoes Resident Evil 4's, and a renewed commitment to pure horror, Capcom is proving that Resident Evil 7 wasn't just a fluke. —Matt Kim

Best Non-Playable Game

Cyberpunk 2077

Fans have been waiting for CD Projekt Red's Cyberpunk 2077 since the game was first announced in 2012. The first trailer dropped in early 2013, but the developer has been utterly quiet about the title since then. E3 2018 marked the first time fans had been able to see another cinematic trailer, teasing out the shape of the digital world based on the Cyberpunk 2020 pen-and-paper RPG. But behind closed doors, the developer showed off how Cyberpunk 2077 will play.

The surprise is that Cyberpunk 2077 is a first-person role-playing game, not the third-person adventure that fans expected from the developer of The Witcher 3. The game plays out like many games in the immersive sim genre, notably Deus Ex: Human Revolution, Deus Ex: Mankind Divided, and Syndicate. Players step into the role of V, a cyberpunk trying to make their way forward in the streets of Night City.

Having seen the gameplay demo, I can say that folks are probably not prepared for the density and detail found in Cyberpunk 2077's Night City. Megabuildings are giant communities that feel like the city section of any other immersive sim. You step out into the street and there are huge crowds walking in every direction, trying to live their own lives. Even in the gameplay trailer, there's some interesting juxtaposition of the grime and decay of Night City's apartments and alleys, and the bright colors and neon signage of the outdoors. And then you step into your car and realize that this isn't just a single city map, and Night City is one amazing, seamless open world to play in.

If someone told me Cyberpunk 2077 was planned for the next generation of consoles, I'd believe them. That's how amazing everything I saw looked technically. And it's all backed by CD Projekt Red's excellent storytelling and commitment to role-playing. No one got to touch it, but Cyberpunk 2077 definitely stands as the best non-playable game of the show. —Mike Williams

The Rest of Our E3 2018 Top 10

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice

Any time we talk about Sekiro, there's always the matter of pointing out that it's not a Souls game. There's a certain context to this ever-present statement. The Souls series is what allowed FromSoftware to rise into mainstream prominence, even though the series is really an evolution of what the developer had done in its older King's Field titles. Armored Core, Otogi, Ninja Blade: you may know of these titles and series, but the average person likely does not. Hence, Sekiro is not a Souls game.

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is very much its own unique creation. There's some inspiration from the Tenchu titles, a series FromSoftware picked up later in life, but it's just that: inspiration. Players take on the role of the Shinobi, a warrior with a transformable arm and the ability to come back from the dead.

The Shinobi is a mobile combatant, with the ability to jump, dodge, and use his grappling hook to move from point to point. There's some light stealth in the game, with the Shinobi able to kill enemies from above or behind to even up the battlefield. Combat in Sekiro will be difficult, but in a different way from the Soulslikes, focusing on a Posture system that can lead to either a quick kill or quick death. Sekiro is FromSoftware telling its new audience that it can do more than just Souls, and that's probably a good thing. —Mike Williams

The Last of Us: Part 2

To be honest, we didn't see a ton of The Last of Us: Part 2. Naughty Dog is still working heavily on the title and it doesn't even have a release date. Ellie returns from the first game as the lead this time around; Joel will still play a role, but it's Ellie's time to shine.

She's not playing around though, as the trailer shows her taking on the game's unnamed religious cult to survive. She hides in tall grass and underneath cars, taking out foes with a gun or bow and arrow. Ellie isn't even above using an enemy as a human shield. The trailer ends with her dispatching her final pursuer with a wicked machete.

Naughty Dog was able to balance equal part brutal violence and emotion in its first run at the world of The Last of Us. Ellie herself is struggling with immense amounts of hate, while also learning to love again. (The kiss with the new character Dina at the beginning and end of the trailer points to at least some downtime from the running and killing.) The Last of Us: Part 2 is already looking great, it's just a matter of Naughty Dog delivering on what the trailer promises. —Mike Williams

Forza Horizon 4

Seasons change everything in Forza Horizon 4, at least according to Microsoft and Playground Games. And you know what? They're right. Seasons add new dynamics to Forza Horizon 4 in two main ways: It changes the types of cars and style of driving you need for each season; and the way it dynamically alters the scenery makes a beautiful game visually surprising.

Not only will you need to alter your vehicles and driving style during different seasons to account for environmental changes like rain and snow, but seeing the world change around you because of the weather is exciting. Previously, the joy of discovering new vistas in Forza Horizon came from finding new locations. With weather, even the same location will change based on what part of the year it is. And of course, with the driving still top-notch, Forza Horizon 4 is now a complete sensory buffet. —Matt Kim

FIFA 19

I always try to drop a sports game in this list, and since I can't talk about NHL 19 yet, I'm going to highlight FIFA 19 instead. As I wrote in my round-up of all the big sports game reveals at E3, FIFA 19 is looking pretty sharp this year. I really like what EA is doing with the new tactics screen, and the locomotion makes a big difference on the field. Everyone has been complaining about ping-pong passing and super high pace matches for ages, and that appears to be fixed. Of course, everyone is probably going to complain next that FIFA 19 is too slow; but to my mind, it's a more tactically nuanced football sim that finally compares somewhat favorably to PES. Combine that with the finale of The Journey and the new Champions League presentation, and FIFA 19 has me very excited for the fall. —Kat Bailey

Assassin's Creed Odyssey

Back when Ubisoft first decided that Assassin's Creed was going to be taking some time off to refocus, I expected that it would be pretty light in terms of changes. Instead, Assassin's Creed Origins began the series' shift away from the action-adventure genre, and more towards new RPG-style level and gear systems. Assassin's Creed Odyssey is merely the next step in that evolution for the series.

Right from the beginning there's an emphasis on choice, with players being able to pick whether they're Alexios or Kassandra. There's now dialogue trees and branching quests. The gear system has been beefed up to allow players more options through engraving, which allows you to improve your gear with recipes found out in the world. Assassin's Creed even has selectable romances this time around! If you thought Origins felt a little like The Witcher 3, Odyssey goes further.

And that's before you get to all the other changes or returning features. The new Conquest Battle system promises large-scale battles befitting a Spartan. Seamless ship sailing and naval combat is back, with players able to recruit and manage their crew. And who doesn't love the ability to kick enemies like Leonidas from 300? Odyssey is shaping up to be something great; the only problem is figuring out where Assassin's Creed goes after this. —Mike Williams

Battlefield 5

It's too bad that everyone is focused on Battlefield 5's gender politics, because as a game it's looking very strong this year. It builds on everything that was great about Battlefield 1 and explores many lesser-known settings in World War 2, the most prominent being Norway. It's basically everything that Call of Duty: WW2 wasn't.

Naturally, this being 2018, it borrows from Fortnite. It has a slightly more stylized aesthetic; a heavier emphasis on cosmetic items (hence the ability to choose your gender in the multiplayer), and the ability to build fortifications. It's going to have battle royale at some point too. But the mode I saw, Grand Operations, was pure Battlefield, encompassing a massive battlefield with vehicles and destructible buildings.

At this point it might be a bit boring to say that Battlefield is a good shooter, but DICE consistently delivers with this franchise. Battlefield 5 is going to be a lot of fun when it releases in October. —Kat Bailey

Tetris Effect

Sublime. Relaxing. These were the words that people were using to describe Tetsuya Mizuguchi's Tetris Effect, which was the surprise hit of E3 2018. It takes what VR does best—putting you inside the music—and applies it to Alexey Pajitnov's classic puzzle game. The combination of quickfire puzzle-solving and psychedelic effects makes for an entrancing experience; and while it's not enough to sell a VR device on its own, it does show that these cumbersome accessories have their positives. —Kat Bailey

Spider-Man

Yes, we complained about Spider-Man's sometimes wonky camera in discussing Insomniac's upcoming superhero game, but its strengths definitely outweigh its weaknesses in this regard. Spider-Man nails the one element that matters most: swinging through New York City. It feels great, making the simple act of getting from mission to mission a delight.

Perhaps more importantly, it captures the overall personality of Spider-Man. Perhaps even more than the Marvel version, which is subordinate to the overarching Avengers storyline, Spider-Man feels faithful to the comics. The quips are spot-on and the villains all match their comic book counterparts. It's the Spider-Man game we've been waiting for ever since Spider-Man 2 blew everyone's mind back on the PS2.

With luck, Spider-Man will inaugurate a new era of triple-A superhero games, which have been curiously MIA ever since licensed movie games went to mobile. As Insomniac shows, Batman need not be the only game in town. —Kat Bailey

Most Exciting Reveal of E3 2018

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is the next game from the team behind Demon’s Souls, Dark Souls, and Bloodborne, so, you know, no pressure or anything. The gameplay trailer at Microsoft’s show came out swinging, literally and metaphorically, with our unnamed Shinobi laying into demons and samurai with swords and grappling hooks.

Head FromSoftware honcho Hidetaka Miyazaki has said the story behind Shadows Die Twice will be a lot more coherent and easier to understand than Bloodborne or the Souls series. Our Shinobi is the bodyguard for a child known only as the Young Lord, but is left for dead after the child is kidnapped. He’s back from the dead with a skeletal arm and a thirst for blood, and it looks like he’ll be cutting a bloody path through feudal Japan.

Bloodborne played like Dark Souls on a speedball, and Sekiro looks like it’s going to play even faster than the former game. You can use the Shinobi's grappling hook to ascend to the tops of buildings and trees in one swift move, as well as use it to launch yourself at enemies that are out of the reach of your blade. The team at FromSoftware are trying something new here, and Shadows Die Twice looks to be all the better for straying out of its comfort zone. —Hirun Cryer

USgamer Community Pick—Best of E3 2018

Cyberpunk 2077

Our Community Pick for Best of E3 2018 was a close one. Capcom's Resident Evil 2 and CD Projekt Red's Cyberpunk 2077 were head to head with votes, but Cyberpunk 2077 wound up victorious by just one single vote. (We tallied votes at around 1 p.m. PT, for the record.) Despite its demo being behind closed doors, news of Cyberpunk 2077 traveled around from the few who were able to see it. Hell, our very own Mike even wrote about it at length. He drew comparisons to the likes of the Deus Ex series, as well as even Syndicate; of course, it has the impeccably detailed quirks customary from the creators of The Witcher 3 too.

Cyberpunk 2077 doesn't have a release date, and heck it seems a bit overambitious for current-gen consoles from what we've heard and seen of it too. Yet that didn't stop the excitement percolating around it. From watching social media flip out about every tiny detail (character creation! First-person! Romantic hook-ups! A vertically dense map instead of a horizontally wide map!) to that killer debut trailer, there's no doubt that Cyberpunk 2077 has won the community over, both ours and the gaming community at large. —Caty McCarthy

Other Staff Favorites From E3 2018

  • Anthem
  • Death Stranding
  • Control
  • Fallout 76
  • Fire Emblem: Three Houses
  • Fist of the North Star: Lost Paradise
  • Hitman 2
  • Just Cause 4
  • Rage 2
  • Sable
  • Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice Wins Game of the Year: The Full List of Winners From Tonight's The Game Awards

Death Stranding gets Best Game Direction as a consolation prize, and Disco Elysium takes home four awards.

Assassin's Creed: The Rebel Collection Shows the Series Can Shine on Switch

This great collection highlights a potential direction for the Assassin's Creed franchise.

Tyrants, Dollhouses, and Rude Geese: Looking Back on 2019's Great Gaming Moments

There were some great moments in video games this year. Let's look back on some of our favorites.

More

Amazon's New World Finds a Firmer Footing With a New Look and More Guidance

The colonial-themed survival MMO returns with a more colorful visual palette.

The Life Is Strange 2 Postmortem: "[W]e Knew That It Wouldn't Have the Same Huge Success Right From the Beginning"

Life Is Strange 2's three creative leads tell us about the season's muted reception, intensive development, and more.

Meet the Player Protesting Call of Duty: Modern Warfare's Violence by Playing as a Pacifist

This artist's act of protesting the violence in the Modern Warfare series is playing them without hurting a soul.