Virtual Spotlight: Harvest Moon Hits a High Point with Friends of Mineral Town

This 2003 Game Boy Advance release feels like a fitting end to Harvest Moon's first act—one that's still intensely playable today.

Retrospective by Bob Mackey, .

With around 25 installments over the last two decades, it's hard for newcomers to know exactly where to start with Natsume's Harvest Moon series.

Sure, conventional wisdom implies picking up the latest game is probably your best bet—after all, a series devoted to such a specific idea has probably only gotten better over time, right? Well, it's a little more complicated than that. Harvest Moon games followed a pretty predictable trajectory until sometime around the PS2 era, when its developers seemingly started from scratch every time planning began for a new sequel. And while this kind of experimentation led to some wildly different experiences, some of the less successful attempts had me pining for the first five years of Harvest Moon, when each installment thoughtfully built off of what came before it.

Ah, the eternal question.

Unless you played each successive sequel upon release, it might be hard to understand Harvest Moon's evolution, so allow me to spell it out for you. 1996 gave us the first Harvest Moon for the Super Nintendo, which, in retrospect, feels like a prototype for what Natsume's farm sim would later become. Based on creator Yasuhiro Wada's GDC presentation from a few years back, it's evident that development mostly focused on getting things working, leaving not much time to figure out how they could work better—having to brush, feed, talk to, and milk eight cows every morning (should you decide to raise livestock) leans a little too close to the drudgery of actual chores.

With the series' foundation established, Wada and his team then built off of this framework with Harvest Moon 64, and then the PlayStation's Harvest Moon: Back to Nature. These games follow the same basic structure as the first, but with plenty of user-friendly touches to cut down on tedium, and a staff of friendly serfs in the form of forest sprites, who can take care of the more repetitive tasks. (Honestly, they really don't seem to mind.)

Today's Wii U Virtual Console release of the Game Boy Advance's Harvest Moon: Friends of Mineral Town couldn't have come at a better time—just a handful of days after Natsume's announcement of a new, retro-style installment in the series. And that's because Friends of Mineral Town is simply the best possible expression of classic Harvest Moon. It features the same addictive loop of hard work and rewards that makes every entry in the series worth a shot, along with all of the farming and livestock options accumulated up to that point—but with a sense of freedom Harvest Moon has been lacking over the last decade. Loading it up today—and with some recent Harvest Moon experience under my belt—I was kind of shocked by how quickly Friends of Mineral Town cuts to the chase.

After about ten minutes of establishing just why you're running your own farm, FoMT cuts the leash and sets you free, with the implication that poking around in its modestly sized world is worthwhile without instruction. Later games gate a ton of necessary functionality until tutorials have the chance to teach you about everything, step by excruciating step. In these earlier Harvest Moons, there's an understanding that the interactions are simple enough that they don't necessarily need to be laid out in full detail—the real challenge lies in coming up with a game plan that allows you to do as many of these interactions as possible over the course of a day. (And honestly, even that's not too difficult.)

Of course, it's necessary to gripe about every Virtual Console release (and a Retronauts tradition!), and Harvest Moon: Friends of Mineral Town certainly doesn't escape my wrath. If anything, FoMT stands as the perfect portable experience, one that's great for keeping your hands and mind busy while watching Netflix or listening to podcasts. And while the Wii U's GamePad is essentially a portable screen, I'm a little baffled as to why Natsume didn't choose the 3DS as the platform for this release—an issue that would definitely be solved by cross-platform play. And while I love blowing up GBA games on my HDTV, Friends of Mineral Town's muted palette—designed for the first Game Boy Advance model—doesn't make for a great big-screen experience. To make things worse, since the game was designed with a 240 by 160 resolution screen in mind, the text looks more like a vision test chart than something you'd find in a video game. It's not quite as bad on the GamePad, but having to repeatedly scan my eyes back and forth across these letters spaced far apart from each other actually began to strain my eyes after a bit.

Still, you shouldn't let these minor complaints get in between you and Friends of Mineral Town. Whenever people ask why I love this series so much, this is typically the game I point to—though I still have a soft spot for Back to Nature. And, honestly, if Natsume wanted to return to their old style and use this as the basis of the upcoming sequel, I'd be on board immediately. Even 12 years later, this doesn't feel like a particularly old game—to me, it's more like the most complete Harvest Moon experience. It could use a bit of modernization here and there—and the choice to play as either a boy or a girl—but I honestly can't think of an expression of Harvest Moon that works better. If you're wondering what this whole "Harvest Moon" thing is about, or were chased away by the tedium of later entries, Friends of Mineral Town could very well convert you.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 3

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for MetManMas #1 MetManMas 3 years ago
    Dunno if you've played it Bob, but 2006's Harvest Moon: Magical Melody on Gamecube was kind of a throwback to classic style Harvest Moon...though it did have some serious pacing problems with the opening and character introductions. But it didn't have the slow tutorial crawl other games have had, and from day one you could start fishing and mining and other farm stuff.

    Also, if you become good friends with the mayor and head carpenter, you can buy up like 2/3rds of the game world for your farming empire.

    But back on topic, while Friends of Mineral Town's translation and coding are severely lacking, it's still one of my favorite portable Harvest Moon games. Next to playing Back to Nature on a PSP, that is. A shame it loses the portability on Wii U, but with more depth than preceding portable HMs, being hands off with the teaching process (Here's some tools and books now GO FARM!), and basically being a portable remake of Back to Nature, it's still one of my favorites.

    Hope it's not too long 'til we see the girl version, it's got more features and a less messy localization.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for grappler51 #2 grappler51 3 years ago
    Always wanted to check out this series and this seems like a good excuse as any! From what I've heard GBA emulation on the 3DS is pretty poor which might be why Nintendo hasn't released any other GBA Virtual Console games on that system beyond the ambassador ones.
    Seems kinda dumb to me though, even the original DS has a (sort of) working homebrew GBA emulator, so it seems like the folks at Nintendo could make a decent one for the 3DS...
    Sign in to Reply