What's the Best Controller of All Time?

What's the Best Controller of All Time?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Let's look back on good game controllers.

This week, we learned more about the peripherals that will be compatible with the PlayStation 5. We learned, also, that the DualShock 4 will work with PS4 games on the platform, but nothing more. RIP DualShock 4.

As we already know, Sony's shaking up the DualShock lineage with the DualSense, a new controller that's changing up the familiar controller series. We thought for this week's Community Question, it'd be fun to reminisce about gamepads. So tell us in comments: What's the best controller of all time, in your opinion?

Mathew Olson Reporter

As soon as we entered the era of offset analog sticks versus aligned analog sticks, humanity was led astray. So, to figure out what the best controller is, I think we have to go back a bit further. My gut says it's the SNES controller, but even then, do we really need those four face buttons plus the left and right shoulder buttons? What's so wrong with the perfect rectangle of the NES controller, apart from the fact that my hands cramp up whenever I try to use it? Anyway, any controller beyond the PS2 DualShock is ineligible for this, in my opinion.

Nadia Oxford Staff Writer

I love the DualShock series. The controller designs don't vary much from version to version—they don't need to, really—but I have a soft spot for the PS4's controller. Yes, even that stupid, useless touchpad (which actually isn't useless for Final Fantasy 14 players, since it doubles as a "mouse" pad). DualShock haters swear by Xbox's most recent controllers (some still swear by The Duke, the Xbox's original behemoth), but Microsoft's controllers don't don't sit in my hand as comfortably as DualShocks. It's true everything is bigger in America, game controllers included, but that becomes a problem when you're 5'0" and you have small hands.

Caty McCarthy Senior Editor

I've always been partial to the DualShock series of controllers from PlayStation over the years, because I have very small hands. (I am just over five feet tall!) I wouldn't say they're "good" though. Just now, I'm dealing with three DualShock 4 controller deaths—one has drift, on one the D-pad just… doesn't work anymore, another has much slighter drift that is manageable. On all of them, I had to put on new rubber pads on the analog sticks because the base rubber wore out. DualShocks have always felt more flimsy compared to Xbox and Nintendo controllers too. I don't know what it is about them. But still, DualShocks remain the most comfortable in my baby-sized hands. I guess that begrudgingly makes them my favorite.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Related articles

What's Your Favorite Nintendo 3DS Game?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Now that the 3DS is officially no more, let's reminisce about our favorites on the portable platform.

What Game Are You Playing This Weekend?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Tell us about what you're currently playing.

What's the Best Sports Game Ever Made?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | It's sports sim season, and we even have a new Tony Hawk game.

Who's Your Favorite RPG Companion?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Who's your best friend 'til the end?

You may also like

The Baroque Beauty of Valkyrie Profile, Tri-Ace's Greatest RPG

Now 20 years old, Valkyrie Profile is one of the PlayStation's finest RPGs.

Doom Eternal Hits Game Pass Next Week, but Only for Xbox

It'll be the first Bethesda game there post-Microsoft acquisition, but PC players need to wait.

Among Us Developers Abandon Sequel Plans and Commit to Updating the Original

The trust-eroding streaming sensation will live on, just not by way of a new release.