What's the Most Painful Game Save You've Ever Lost? Players Share Their Stories

What's the Most Painful Game Save You've Ever Lost? Players Share Their Stories

A cartridge's save battery is finite. Just like a parent's love.

Have you ever lost a game save that was so important to you, so precious, that thinking back to its loss gives you a case of the galloping shudders? I believe we all have, even if we don't want to drag those painful memories back into the light. But let's not suffer in silence any longer. It's time for a focus group.

Last week on Twitter, writer Andy Kelly asked, "What's the most devastating save file you ever lost?" He goes on to recall how he was 35 hours into Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic when some nogoodnik broke into his house and lifted his Crystal Xbox.

That's a real "ouch" moment for Mr. Kelly; no arguing that. But it also got me thinking about how game saves are much more secure than they used to be thanks to internal console media storage and cloud saves. The aforementioned Knights of the Old Republic save only went missing after a jackhole lifted the entire Xbox (the Xbox was the first console with a hard drive). By contrast, saving to cartridge batteries and memory cards was a dangerous game, so to speak. Heck, saving to an off-brand PlayStation memory card back in the day was as iffy as sticking a fork in an electric socket before checking the main breaker. Sure, you'd get dozens of game save slots instead of the mere 15 the official memory card afforded you, but at what price?

A fifty-fifty chance of turning on your PlayStation to find out your 60-hour Final Fantasy 7 Gold Chocobo game save was demolished by gremlins overnight. That's what price.

My personal heartbreak dead game saves started long before the age of bootleg PlayStation memory cards, however. As a life-long fan of RPGs dating back to the '80s, I was something of a test subject for battery saves, a new-fangled way of saving your progress in lengthy NES and SNES games. Battery saves were often used in place of password systems, but the trade-off was double-edged. Sure, you didn't have to deal with the nightmare of copying lengthy passwords full of confusing characters (Is that a capital "I," and "L," or a "1?" Look carefully; hours of Castlevania 2 progress depend on it), but battery life is finite. When the cartridge's battery loses its charge, poof goes your game saves. If you're really unlucky, the battery might even corrode and ruin the game's circuit board.

It's impossible to predict when a storage battery will give up the ghost. I don't doubt there are some old cartridge games out there still faithfully clinging to the data they were entrusted with. Sadly, my SNES RPG library is filled with more heartbreak than stories of dogged loyalty. Losing my Final Fantasy 3 / 6 save in the mid-Aughts was particularly painful. I bought the game close to launch day and put over 60 hours on my main save, which had all its characters named after the Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers (look, the franchise took off around the same time and I had a massive crush on Tommy). That's a lot of effort to get flushed down the john, to say nothing of them memories I accumulated going through what eventually became one of my all-time favorite games.

Less devastating but no less annoying was renting an RPG and discovering its save battery was banjaxed. This happened to me often when I was a kid who rented (expensive, hard-to-find) NES Dragon Quest games instead of buying them. I put several hours of work into Dragon Quest 2, then sat slack-jawed in front of the screen the next day when I discovered my option to "START A NEW QUEST" or "CONTINUE A QUEST" slimmed down to "BEGIN A NEW QUEST." Then it happened again. And again, because I was the kind of kid who'd slam her BMX into a brick wall twice just to make sure it still hurt the second time around. To be fair, I had no idea that a faulty save battery was my problem, and I should've just returned the game to the rental store right away. I sure remembered "bad save batteries are a thing" after that Sisyphean experience, though.

Going back to Andy Kelly's initial topic of discussion: Feel free to air out any deep psychological wounds you suffered from your own lost game saves. Let's also give thanks to how the problem's been nearly wiped out by hard media storage backed up by cloud saves. Granted, the industry's shift from cartridges and CDs to digital has been disastrous for game preservation, but I guess there's no great loss without some small gain.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Nadia Oxford

Staff Writer

Nadia has been writing about games for so long, only the wind and the rain (or the digital facsimiles thereof) remember her true name. She's written for Nerve, About.com, Gamepro, IGN, 1UP, PlayStation Official Magazine, and other sites and magazines that sling words about video games. She co-hosts the Axe of the Blood God podcast, where she mostly screams about Dragon Quest.

Read this next

The First Three Dragon Quests Finally Leave Their Mobile Prison For Switch

Erdrick's violent kids are about to run rampant on your Switch.

The 16-bit Console Wars Return on Axe of the Blood God

The Blood God drops listeners in a time warp back to 1994.

Why Dragon Quest Failed to Make it In America 30 Years Ago

Nintendo tried its best to make the West love RPGs, but culture—and more importantly, timing—was against the attempt.

EarthBound’s 25th Anniversary Makes us Pine for Classic Instruction Books

Earthbound's player guide is a great example of the effort publishers expended trying to make the West fall in love with RPGs.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Character Ban Sets Off Massive Debate

Dragon Quest's Hero is a random character... possibly too random.

Dragon Quest's Hero Joins Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Today, Alongside A New Patch

A new stage, music, and some Mii Fighters enter the fray too.

More Opinions

Kunai Is The Best Feeling Platformer I've Played Since Dead Cells

This tiny robot samurai wins with precise platforming action.

Apple Arcade Brings Game Pricing Concerns Back to the Forefront

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Will successful subscription services turn into their own walled gardens?

Apple Arcade is Way Cooler Than You Think. Here are 10 Games to Check Out

Apple Arcade has dozens of neat games, so we highlighted 10 from its launch lineup that are a bit under the radar.

At Last, FIFA 20's Career Mode is Interesting Again - Review Impressions

Some much-needed improvements have a major impact on FIFA 20's much-maligned career mode.

More on NES

The First Three Dragon Quests Finally Leave Their Mobile Prison For Switch

Erdrick's violent kids are about to run rampant on your Switch.

Why Dragon Quest Failed to Make it In America 30 Years Ago

Nintendo tried its best to make the West love RPGs, but culture—and more importantly, timing—was against the attempt.

Starting Screen | EarthBound’s 25th Anniversary Makes us Pine for Classic Instruction Books

Earthbound's player guide is a great example of the effort publishers expended trying to make the West fall in love with RPGs.

Where Nintendo Switch Online Has Gone Wrong

The reasons Nintendo's online service is flaccid, and what it can do to pump things up.

Sorry, but a Zelda 2 Remake Isn't Being Planned

Inti Creates boss would like you to know he's not working on it.

Recovered Super Mario Bros. Super Show Animation Cels Bring Us Back to the Franchise's Weirdest, Most Aimless Days

If you can't mix Super Mario Bros. with Billy Idol, then what's the point of life?

More Role Playing Games Games

Apple Arcade is Way Cooler Than You Think. Here are 10 Games to Check Out

Apple Arcade has dozens of neat games, so we highlighted 10 from its launch lineup that are a bit under the radar.

We Dare You to Eat This Pile of Ancient Pokemon Food

Expiration dates are just suggestions.

The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening Review

Come sail away with Link. Again.