Why Play Animal Crossing, Anyway? (A Primer)

Curious what the big deal is about Nintendo's quirky attempt at the simulation genre?

We gamer types tend to look down our nose at anything that doesn't quite fall into the well-defined boundaries of our preferred genres and game types, and yet Animal Crossing commands a thriving fan base within the ranks of the much-touted "core gamer" demographic. This, despite its utter lack of conflict, violence, or concrete purpose. Despite its so-cute-you'll-barf graphics. Despite the fact that character customization revolves around fashion choices rather than statistics or skill trees.

Animal Crossing demands nothing more of players than a few minutes' daily play and some savvy financial planning. Your objectives consist of paying off a house loan, collecting the neatest knickknacks, and dressing your character up in the finest style. It sounds absolutely childish, and the cutesy graphical style doesn't do much to discourage that perception. And yet, somehow, a goodly number of Animal Crossing fanatics are adults -- people who not only don't seem to link up as the game's "proper" audience, but people who already deal with the game's menial tasks in their day-to-day lives. So why on earth would someone sweating out a mortgage in the real world want to spend their free time doing the exact same thing?

The answer: While Animal Crossing may not look like the typical core-oriented video game, it tickles the same primal pleasure zones as its more "serious" cousins. While it lacks a single ultimate goal, it offers plenty of minor objectives for players to pursue at their discretion. Besides upgrading your house to its maximum size, you also can compete for a high score with your interior decorating skills. (This is more challenging than you might expect, demanding you make canny use of matching item sets, appropriate decor for the month, and the principles of feng shui while still trying to express your own tastes.) You can race to deck out the local museum with a sample of every kind of bug, fish, fossil, and classic artwork to exist in Animal Crossing's world, tasks held up by seasonal specificity, rarity, and the fact that most of the artwork you'll acquire (one piece per week) turns out to be fake.

As multiplayer has sunk its hooks ever deeper into Animal Crossing's design, an MMO-like loot/bragging rights vibe has grown more prominent in the game's design as well. You have no less than three different ways to show off your town to others in New Leaf -- invite them in for an actual visit, trade your house design via Street Pass, and share an ethereal vision of your home online through the Dream Suite -- and the towns in question allow for a remarkable amount of customization. Besides the long-standing option of planting trees and flowers, you can also install public works like campsites and benches, put up photo booths, decorate the ground with pattern tiles, and more.

Even if you settle on simply building up your house as a goal, much of the appeal of Animal Crossing comes from the varied ways in which you can go about this. At the beginning, your only real sources of earning cash are selling loose fruit and seashells for a pittance, but in time you gain the tools and means to become very efficient at piling up loot. You can replace unproductive trees with "perfect" versions of your local crop or valuable foreign fruit collected from other people's villages. You can capture bugs and fish; once the tropical island opens up, this becomes an insanely efficient way of racking up huge money (assuming you have the patience to capture rare beetles and sharks). For the truly serious player, though, tremendous wealth can be had by investing in commodities (turnips), conferring with friends, and visiting someone else's town when the price of turnips spikes.

You don't have to be a Wall Street shark to make a living, though. Slow and steady also does the trick. Every day, new fossils appear to be dug up and a single rock inexplicably produces money when struck. By picking the money stone clean and selling off any fossils the museum doesn't need, you can easily net 20,000 bells per day or so for a 15-minute tour of town. It all really depends on how much you want to play each day, how married you are to the concept of a daily routine, and whether you see money as an end or simply a means.

Like I said in my review, Animal Crossing feels in many ways like the proto-social game. It's a bit aimless, it involves showing off to your friends (or begging them for stuff), sometimes it can feel like busywork. What sets it apart from an ocean of callow Facebook games is that it holds on to a sort of Protestant work ethic; Animal Crossing doesn't let you advance with a few lazy mouse clicks but instead metes out progress as a reward for actual effort. You can choose to game the system, or not, but the milestones you accomplish seem commensurate with your investment, whether that boils down to time and persistence or simply some canny mental arithmetic to sort out the ideal strategy for raking in big bucks as much as possible.

Plus, if you play it right you can eventually cram your home full of Nintendo trinkets like Triforces and Metroid tubes. Try that in your Facebook games. (Well, you know. Legally.)

Tagged with 3DS Handhelds, Animal Crossing: New Leaf, Articles, Nintendo, Simulations.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

"The Nightmare Is Far From Over:" How the Artist Behind Garfield Gameboy'd Dreamed up His Four-Color Horror Show

LumpyTouch's mock-playthrough of an unreleased Garfield horror game is a terrifying, pus-filled labor of love.

The 25 Best Nintendo Switch Games

Our rotating list of the best Nintendo Switch games, now bigger than before!

Sega Explains Why Team Sonic Racing Opening Cutscene is Missing on Switch

The size limitations on the Switch cartridge is to blame.

Apex Legends Downward Spiral Continues After Reported Second Consecutive Decline in Revenue

Analysts report double-digit losses for Respawn's battle royale.

Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 Adds More X-Men to its Roster

It's not just Wolverine showing up for the fun.

More Articles

What Will PlayStation Productions Mean for Video Game Movies?

Sony plants its foot and vows to make better video game films. Will they be more successful where others have failed?

What's Your Favorite Arcade Memory?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Following Street Fighter 3: 3rd Strike, a legendary arcade game, turning 20 this week, we look back on our favorite arcade experiences.

Which Pokemon Would Be Your Partner in Detective Pikachu's Ryme City?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | "[Insert Pokemon name here]! I choose you!"

More on 3DS

The Best Resident Evil Games: Every Resident Evil Ranked From Worst to Best

In this ranking of the Resident Evil games, we decide which ones are Tyrant-grade and which ones are basic, brain-dead zombies.

Geodude Evolved into the Mascot of Japan’s Iwate Prefecture

Geodude might get massacred by Grass-types in Pokemon battles, but he's a real swell mascot.

Detective Pikachu is on Track to be the Highest Grossing Video Game Movie Ever, But It Might Not Be Enough

Detective Pikachu is on track to become the highest grossing video game film, but it's not necessarily the juggernaut we expected.

Which Pokemon Would Be Your Partner in Detective Pikachu's Ryme City?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | "[Insert Pokemon name here]! I choose you!"

Detective Pikachu Roundtable: What We Think After Seeing the New Live-Action Pokemon Movie

Which Pokemon won Detective Pikachu? Is it the best video game movie ever? And who is the best human character outside of Bill Nighy?

More Simulation Games

The 25 Best Steam Games: Now Updated for 2019

A rotating list of the best games on Steam may seem impossible on the surface, but against all odds, we've done it!

Frostbite's Next-Gen Hair Tech Demo Is Super Realistic And Definitely Not Creeping Me Out

I am totally fine with the lifelike hair dolls and the tech that powers them.

Outer Wilds Will Launch As Timed Epic Exclusive, And Backers Don't Seem Happy

The Fig-funded space exploration sim won't be coming to Steam right away.