Why Some Super Mario Maker 2 Players are Thinking About Going Back to the Original

Why Some Super Mario Maker 2 Players are Thinking About Going Back to the Original

Players dismay over the mechanical changes in the level-building sequel.

In my review, I said that Super Mario Maker 2 could've just been a port, but Nintendo added and changed enough to make a proper sequel. Well, with the full release of the game, the veteran Mario Maker community has finally gotten the chance to dive in and see what those changes are. In terms of mechanics, Super Mario Maker is entirely like past Mario titles, but in contrast, Super Mario Maker 2 isn't entirely like its predecessor.

If you're a more casual player, you might not notice these specific changes. A number of these mechanics matter for veteran course makers, however, because they're key to so-called "Kaizo" levels. Based on the old ROM hack Kaizo Mario World, these are very hard levels that require precise movement and unique tricks to overcome. These tricks included grabbing objects in a spin jump, or engaging with certain objects in mid-air after throwing them. Kaizo course makers and connoisseurs know all of these tricks by heart, and in Super Mario Maker 2, some either do not work, or work differently.

In the latter category, players have reported that a number of mid-air object jumps still work in Super Mario Maker 2, but the timing is different. These moves require players to be holding an object, jump, release the object, and then interact with it in mid-air. This includes mid-air P-Switch, Spring Block, and POW Block jumps. They're key for some high jumps, or continuous movement while activating a P-Switch or POW Block. The timing on these moves in Super Mario Maker 2 has changed, but they're still doable.

One thing that's not doable and is key to some Kaizo levels is the Spin Jump Grab. This allowed Mario to spin jump and still grab an item in mid-air. The spin jump is important, because it allowed Mario to touch and bounce off of objects that would normally kill him. Combined with the mid-air moves above, this allowed Mario another odd way to get through levels. Unfortunately, the spin jump grab is gone completely, according to streamer PTKen, who also tested a number of other mechanics.

Another change is the ability to jump off objects in lava. In the previous Mario Maker, you could drop an object in the lava, and before it sank completely, you could jump off it. In Super Mario Maker 2, you instead fall right into the lava; the object essentially ceases to exist once dropped in lava. This change was confirmed by streamer and speedrunner David "GrandPOObear" Hunt on Twitter.

There are several other mechanical shifts as well, including the fact that Galloombas no longer bounce back when thrown against an object, players can't fly with the Mario World Cape inside a Drybone shell, and Mario is no longer pushed out of walls. The Poodoboo trick, which some course makers used to put objects in-between grid spaces in the Course Maker, also does not work in Super Mario Maker 2. Basically, there are a whole bunch of techniques and mechanics that Super Mario Maker course makers and players relied on, that operate a lot differently in the sequel.

All this on top of issues like the 32-course limit for uploading, which hits the avid course makers the hardest, or the inability to edit downloaded courses from other players. Many in the community were expecting a smooth transition from one game to the next, with the sequel not changing mechanics, just adding more features, themes, and items on top. Instead, Nintendo has changed the feel and mechanics in several places, meaning course makers have to shift and remix their concepts for the new game.

Perhaps these changes are in flux though. Nintendo has already promised the ability to play with friends in online multiplayer in a future update, so perhaps some of these mechanics and missing features can be amended in a later patch. As it stands, some course makers are still looking longingly at Super Mario Maker on the Wii U.

If you're not a long-time Mario Maker community member, you might not miss these changes at all. For everyone else, Super Mario Maker 2 is still a fantastic experience, even if you only play by yourself. Super Mario Maker 2 is available on Nintendo Switch today, and we look forward to diving further into it in the coming weeks and months.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Mike Williams

Reviews Editor

M.H. Williams is new to the journalism game, but he's been a gamer since the NES first graced American shores. Third-person action-adventure games are his personal poison: Uncharted, Infamous, and Assassin's Creed just to name a few. If you see him around a convention, he's not hard to spot: Black guy, glasses, and a tie.

Read this next

Check Out This Super Mario Maker 2 Course From the Yooka-Laylee Developers

Playtonic is just the first indie dev Nintendo will shout out via Mario Maker 2.

Latest Super Mario Maker 2 Patch Finally Lets You Play Online With Friends

On top of this multiplayer and quality of life-focused update, Nintendo says new course parts are on the way.

The 25 Best Nintendo Switch Games

Our rotating list of the best games on Switch, now updated for the Nintendo Switch Lite release!

Where Nintendo Switch Online Has Gone Wrong

The reasons Nintendo's online service is flaccid, and what it can do to pump things up.

Nintendo Says There is No Switch Exchange Program

Nintendo of America denies last week's reports of Switch exchanges.

Man vs. Mario Maker 2: Hardcore Jumps, Airship Explosions, and Spiny Rescues

We're back with another round-up of some of the most interesting courses in Super Mario Maker 2!

More Opinions

Starting Screen | Starting Screen: Please Stop Putting Big Spiders In Video Games

I'm tired of it, and I don't have a good reason for it!

Blizzard's Very Bad October Just Keeps Getting Worse

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Blizzard's ban on Hearthstone player Blitzchung catches the ire of Republicans and Democrats alike.

Baldur's Gate's Complex Interface Translates Surprisingly Well to Switch

Beamdog's Infinity Engine collections find great ways to bring those games to consoles.

More on Switch

The Glory and Carnage of Rocket League's Underground Fight Club

The unofficial league where pros and unknowns alike battle head-to-head for honor and viewer cash pools.

Doom 64 Port Gets New Trailer, Will Release as Pre-Order Bonus Alongside Doom Eternal

A delay for Doom Eternal on Switch also has ramifications for Doom 64 on Nintendo's platform.

The Outer Worlds Review: To Boldly Go Where Mega-Corps Have Gone Before

Seek out new life and new civilizations, and then steal stuff from them.

Monster of the Week: How Amnesia: The Dark Descent's Water Lurker Became the Scariest Nautical Nightmare Since Jaws

Co-designer Thomas Grip on sculpting Amnesia's scariest monster, which happens to also be the only one you never see.

Fortnite Medals Punch Card - How to Earn New Medals and Refresh the Punch Card

This is our full guide to the new Fortnite Medals system, including how to earn them, and times for the Punch Card refresh.

More Action Games

Fortnite Medals Punch Card - How to Earn New Medals and Refresh the Punch Card

This is our full guide to the new Fortnite Medals system, including how to earn them, and times for the Punch Card refresh.

Control's New PC Patch Forces You to Launch Through the Epic Games Store [Update: It's Being Fixed]

An Epic representative tells USG that DRM and store authentication decisions are up to developers and publishers.

Microsoft Claims Xbox Game Pass Subscribers Play More Games and More Genres

The average Game Pass user is apparently playing—and buying—more games than they used to.