Wonderful Memories, Crummy-Looking Postcard: Ys Memories of Celceta Review

Falcom's latest adventure may not be beautiful, but it has a great personality.

Review by Jeremy Parish, .

To properly appreciate what makes Ys: Memories of Celceta so remarkable, you need to understand a little bit about where it comes from. In the same way that Ys: The Oath in Felghana was a remake of Ys III built on the Ys Seven engine, Celceta likewise recasts Ys IV in the series' modern mold. [Correction: Felghana was built on the Ys VI engine.]

The oddity here comes from the fact that there were two different games published under the name Ys IV, and neither of them were designed by series' creators Falcom. One of those Ys IVs (Mask of the Sun) has been blessed as being more canonical than the other (Dawn of Ys), but neither totally represented Falcom's perspective on the series. So in a sense, Celceta represents the first "real" Ys IV, even though it's not being published under that name.

Since both versions of Ys IV failed to appear in English in an official capacity, I honestly don't know enough about them to be able to point out how much material or influence Celceta draws from either of them, if any. Nor does it actually matter, really, to the enjoyment of the game. It stands perfectly well on its own merits. Nevertheless, knowing the nebulous origins of the game helps paint a clearer picture of why, exactly, it works the way it does -- which is to say, why it spends so much time exploring the past of series protagonist Adol Christin, and why it plays like a mixture of Ys Seven and The Oath in Felghana.

We've moved well beyond the days of running headlong into enemies and hoping for the best, but this Ys is every bit as speedy as the old ones.

Like the last Ys remake, Celceta appears to be running on the same technology that powered Ys Seven. In this case, though, that's both a curse and a blessing. On the plus side, it means the action is every bit as snappy and smooth as you'd expect; Ys has always prided itself on being the fastest action RPG franchise going, and Celceta upholds that tradition. Like the other PSP-era titles in the series, much of its celerity stems from a heavy emphasis on evasive maneuvers and instant character-switching.

Here, protagonist Adol teams up with a rotating cast of support characters, including a bruiser-type stand-in for his pal Dogi named Duren, an archer who fights much like Ys Seven's Aisha, and others, each of whom deal different types of damage: Slash, pierce, crush, elemental, etc. Enemies in turn bear resistances and suffer weaknesses to each type, so in order to fight most efficiently (and earn the most experience and loot bonuses), you'll need to swap constantly, and instantly, between your party members.

The inactive characters operate under their own AI, which honestly is probably going to be a better warrior than you -- computer-controlled heroes do a remarkable job of dodging enemy attacks. While facing more dangerous foes, though, you'll need to adjust their AI settings to a more defensive style (through a simplified version of the AI grid in Super NES classic Secret of Mana, to which modern-day Ys makes a far more satisfying follow-up than anything Square has managed to come up with in the past 20 years). While I still feel like the lack of multiplayer represents a missed opportunity in modern Ys, it's an understandable design choice; it would muddle up the character-swap mechanics around which combat revolves.

Your protagonists wield a small but effective array of abilities, but none are so important as the ability to null damage by dodging attacks. A perfectly executed dodge (aka "Flash move!") causes time to slow around your character, giving you a chance to score some extra hits or, in the case of enemies with dangerous splash-damage effects, move safely out of range. The timing on this evasive maneuver is far narrower than it was in Ys Seven, so you can't simply spam it and hope for the best; you really need to learn to read your enemies' tells in order to predict their actions. This is especially true for bosses, which tend to be screen-filling monstrosities with tremendous attack power and range.

Like those graphics? "Celceta" is Latin for "cataract surgery."

Unfortunately, that Ys Seven legacy technology makes this slightly more difficult than it ought to. Far be it from me to join the babbling masses complaining about any game with less-than-perfect graphics and sub-60fps frame rates, but Celceta's graphical imperfections can sometimes affect how it plays. The entire game appears to be running at PSP resolution, doubled up for Vita and loaded down with blur and bloom lighting to mask its jagged edges. There's a smeary quality to the entire world, along with a distracting stutteriness in the animations. These herky-jerky movements mostly affect distant monsters at the edge of periphery, but they can sometimes impact the larger enemies as well... that is, the most dangerous foes, the ones whose movements you need to be able to read most effectively.

While these visual quirks can annoy, they mercifully don't detract from the game too much. It's a fundamentally fast-paced action RPG that manages to avoid the flaws that bogged down its predecessors. Its multi-character system creates much more variety than The Oath in Felghana's stripped-down action; the boss battles in particular feel much richer and more strategic than the arcade-style showdowns in Felghana. At the same time, the story manages to be far more compact than Ys Seven's endless jabbering without feeling slight. In a lot of ways, it's the ideal expression of the style Falcom has been refining for nearly a decade.

Celceta also presents an appealing premise to get things running: Adol is sent to map the mysterious forest from which the game takes its name, and much of the quest unfolds through small missions and elective quests. The "sea of trees" actually feels as dangerous as its in-game reputation suggests thanks to tough foes with nasty attacks and the presence of boss-caliber "normal" monsters in nearly every section of the map. I think a big part of what I like about Celceta is how much it reminds me of Etrian Odyssey: You're out mapping a big, mysterious forest until your resources run dry, and every once in a while you bump into a giant monster that will crush you like a bug. The spirit is similar, even if here it's wrapped in the trappings of an action RPG instead of a dungeon crawler.

Whatever Celceta's place in Ys lore, it amounts to a pretty solid adventure by any standard, even if it looks pretty rough around the edges. Falcom continues to refine the series' current direction, and each new Ys is more entertaining than the last.

In Summary

  • Visuals: A little painful on the eyes -- Celceta looks like a PSP game upscaled badly with a soft filter smashed over top. But it's so fast-paced you'll probably only notice during the cut scenes.
  • Sound: It's Falcom, and that means great music. The partial voice acting is tolerable enough that it probably won't make you angry.
  • Interface: Pretty much no-nonsense; thankfully the developers had the good sense to limit back-touch elements to rarely-used functions.
  • Lasting Appeal: A fairly meaty adventure, and for the truly dedicated you can tackle it on different difficulty levels.

With plenty of fast-paced (and frequently challenging) action, Ys: Memories of Celceta fills in a gap in the series' history with aplomb. It offers a nice balance between story and combat -- in fact, its biggest shortcoming is strictly technical. A great addition to the Vita's library and the Ys franchise alike.

4 /5

Wonderful Memories, Crummy-Looking Postcard: Ys Memories of Celceta Review Jeremy Parish Falcom's latest adventure may not be beautiful, but it has a great personality. 2013-12-09T21:00:00-05:00 4 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 14

  • Avatar for cscaskie #1 cscaskie 4 years ago
    This game was the title that finally forced my hand and made me buy a Vita. I've been an Ys fan for many years, and I cannot wait to play it.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for touchofkiel #2 touchofkiel 4 years ago
    For anyone looking to try out the series, all three PSP games are on sale right now at $7.50 on PSN (with very little fanfare, it seems).

    In any case, it was a good way for me to try out the series. If I like it, I'll be sure to pick this new one up.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Funny_Colour_Blue #3 Funny_Colour_Blue 4 years ago
    @cscaskie Same, Ys Seven in my mind was the only game that justified owning a PSP. So once I heard Ys IV was headed to the VITA I finally caved and bought one.

    This is pretty much the only game I'm looking forward to this hoilday season unfortunately.

    I miss the days when JRPGs were plentiful and could still be played on consoles.

    ...I would very much like JRPGs to return to consoles. I don't really care all that much for "graphics". I would just like something I could hook up to the TV.

    :( Edited December 2013 by Funny_Colour_Blue
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #4 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    @Funny_Colour_Blue Well, hey, there's always Vita TV.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jonleo75 #5 jonleo75 4 years ago
    I finished the Japanese version of this game. Jeremy's pretty much spot-on with the game.

    I stuck it through the entire game with Adol, Duren and Karna. Honestly, it does a better job at being an action RPG than even Diablo 3.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Stealth20k #6 Stealth20k 4 years ago
    really good game
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for brionfoulke91 #7 brionfoulke91 4 years ago
    @jonleo75 Doing a better job at being an action game than Diablo 3 isn't saying much. The Diablo games get worse with each entry.

    Meanwhile, the Y's games seem to be getting better with every entry. I'm very happy that companies like Falcom are still around, and are still outputting great games.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for GustinHardy #8 GustinHardy 4 years ago
    This has become my morning commute game and really enjoying it. My first ever Ys game so I think I may want to dig further back in the series afterward.Edited December 2013 by GustinHardy
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for phatcorns #9 phatcorns 4 years ago
    Jeremy, you are really hating on graphics lately. You called link between worlds ugly and I thought it was beautiful. I'm wondering if your tastes are just much different from mine.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #10 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    @phatcorns That's 'cause A Link Between World's graphic design looked like butt (even though it ran smoothly, so it worked out). Conversely, Ys has good art direction but technically runs like butt to the point that it can interfere with the game. A spade = a spade. Edited December 2013 by jeremy.parish
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for DiscordInc #11 DiscordInc 4 years ago
    I must admit that this, along with Gravity Rush and a couple other titles, really makes me want a Vita.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Funny_Colour_Blue #12 Funny_Colour_Blue 4 years ago
    @DiscordInc Gravity Rush really is something everyone has to play, even if you don't own a Vita.

    It's feels like this really great PS2 game with next-gen features; Instead of reaching for the right analog stick - like you normally would to control the camera - I found myself turning the Vita itself, with my own two hands, because it just felt more intuitive.

    Like, It's really weird, but it's so cool! I don't think I've ever played anything else like it and this was just from the demo alone. Edited December 2013 by Funny_Colour_Blue
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mganai #13 mganai 4 years ago
    @jeremy.parish So this one, like Ys VI, is still choppy? Bugger.

    Between frame rate and visuals, I'll always take the former.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Hegerman #14 Hegerman 4 years ago
    I really want this!! Hopefully it will hit PS+ or a random sale before I am done playing Rainbow Moon ... Another GREAT JRPG on the Vita that I am REALLY getting into!!
    Sign in to Reply