Yo-Kai Watch 3DS Review: Borrowed Time

Level-5's monster-collecting RPG might not be wholly original, but it's perfect for lapsed Pokemon fans looking for a fresh take on a reliable formula.

Review by Bob Mackey, .

As someone who loved the original Pokemon games, I consider it a personal failing that I've barely been able to maintain enthusiasm for Nintendo's monster-collecting RPG since the close of the 20th century.

But maybe it's not completely my fault. Every time I start up a new Pokemon sequel, the fun runs out just as I realize I'm going through the motions all over again. But, regardless of what I think, this sense of tradition is the key to Pokemon's colossal success: Every game remains simple enough to ostensibly serve as someone's first RPG, while the series' pervasive sense of familiarity encourages returning players to dismiss the big picture and instead focus on the minor additions. Strip away the many coats of paint added by developer Game Freak over the past two decades, and, at its heart, Pokemon is still a simple, 8-bit RPG—one that nonetheless supports varying degrees of obsession.

With this desire to love Pokemon buried deep within my soul, it shouldn't be surprising to hear I took to Yo-Kai Watch so quickly; it takes the same basic concept, and reworks it for a generation far removed from the fairly antiquated experiences Pokemon leans on. It may be a little too simple for some, but Yo-Kai Watch understands the importance of keeping your attention at every possible moment. And while it's not without its problems, developer Level-5's relentless efforts to keep players engaged brought me back to those days where, as a slightly ashamed 16 year old, my life was consumed by a world of marketable monsters depicted in four stunning shades of green.

Gotta Catch 'Em All

Like Pokemon, Yo-Kai Watch revolves around a world overloaded with strange and mysterious creatures, though they aren't as much of a fact of life in the seriously non-Japanese setting of Springdale—in fact, they're invisible unless you're one of the select few wearing the titular Yo-Kai Watch. Essentially, Yo-Kai exist as a way to explain problems in the world, as each mischievous spirit serves a particular negative function in society: one makes you forget things, another makes you gossip, yet another helps you procrastinate, and so on. In this sense, Yo-Kai Watch really feels like the world as depicted through a very child-like lens: All of those complex, adult problems can just be dismissed with "a spirit did it." (One of the earliest missions in the game involves dispatching a Yo-Kai who's making your parents argue.)

If you've played previous 3DS Level-5 RPGs like Fantasy Life, Yokai Watch should feel pretty familiar. Like its predecessor, it also takes an episodic approach, with plenty of MMO-style quests surrounding the main objective to keep you and your party busy. Along with the usual fetch quests and "kill [X] number of [Y]" missions, Yo-Kai Watch's world is littered with things to do and find. With the touch of a button, you can bring up a radar to see if any Yo-Kai are nearby, then expose them with a variant of the extremely popular "hidden object" genre.

Even with its fairly urban setting, Yokai Watch manages to make exploring a cityscape interesting, and tucks away plenty of hidden treasures, mini-dungeons, and mysteries for players to find throughout its dense environments, including—in what feels like a nod to Pokemon's Hidden Machines—some you can only access once you level up your watch. And the best part about all of this exploration is you essentially opt into fighting hostile Yo-Kai. Encounters are limited to specific areas—where they can still be avoided—and if you spot a Yo-Kai that, for whatever reason, you don't want to fight, it's easy to back out of a potential battle.

And it's these battles that are, perhaps, Yo-Kai Watch's biggest departure from Pokemon. Instead of a typical, turn-based affair, its enemy encounters act more like Final Fantasy XIII's, where players take on the role of an RPG party coach who directs a mostly autonomous team. At first, this system may seem a bit too simple, but it soon opens itself up to plenty of possibilities. The six Yo-Kai in your party, for instance, exist as pie pieces in a circle, and placing them adjacent to members of the same "tribe"—think "type" in Pokemon terms—can bring passive benefits during enemy encounters. Mostly, battles feel like a manageable form of plate-spinning: Keeping health full with items, and turning your Yo-Kai wheel to bring weak spirits out of the fight and healthy ones in.

While your Yo-Kai act on their own, that doesn't mean you'll just be sitting back and making sure they don't lose too much HP. If anything, Yo-Kai watch wants to keep you engaged during every second of battle, even if your party runs on cruise control. Once a Yo-Kai's soul meter charges to capacity, you can then use their signature "Soultimate" move, which typically unleashes damage and/or status effects against all of your opponents.

And since performing these moves involves playing a seconds-long micro-game on the touchscreen, you also sacrifice time you could be healing or performing other non-automated duties in battle. The only downside is you'll be playing the same micro-games a lot, and the limited amount available aren't necessarily assigned to certain Yo-Kai. The same Soultimate move that required you to trace various shapes on a previous turn, for instance, may have you spinning a wheel on another turn. Granted, it's fun to see a Yo-Kai's flashy, silly superpower pulled off effectively, but after playing Undertale, I was a little disappointed with how little Yo-Kai Watch plays with the idea of using micro-games during RPG battles.

While Yo-Kai do most of the fighting on their own, the battle system has a way of keeping you constantly moving between different duties. The "target" function allows you to direct your Yokai's attention to a particular enemy, and lets you shoot down treasure-filled spirit orbs that randomly float through battle scenes. And if your Yo-Kai come down with a status effect, you can rotate them out of battle and play another touch-based microgame to get them back on their feet—and earn a bit of extra experience for doing so. Even if the UI looks like it was designed by Playskool, there's a surprising amount of stuff packed into this battle system; the first few bosses actually handed my butt to me before I fully wrapped my mind around Yo-Kai Watch's version of RPG multitasking.

You Know, for Kids!

If you're looking for the surprising amount of depth Pokemon's gained over the years, Yo-Kai Watch may disappoint you a bit. The "tribe" system isn't nearly as essential as Pokemon types; since it's mostly used as a way to bring about passive benefits in battle, you won't necessarily be setting out to develop a well-rounded team. Most of the time I rolled with a Yo-Kai wheel featuring just two or three different tribes in order to have a few boosts to choose from during battle. And there's not a whole lot of customization, either: Your Yo-Kai can equip an accessory, but their moveset is prescribed, and, to be honest, assembling a party often boils down to choosing the monsters you like the most—or ones with Soultimate moves you find super effective. As expected, they can evolve, and you can combine Yo-Kai using a very Persona-like system, but if you plan your battles correctly, there's really no wrong way to assemble a party.

A lot of this simplicity can be chalked up to the fact that Yo-Kai Watch is made for the younger set, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. The low numbers, charming world, and constant micro-games throughout actually reminded me a lot of the Paper Mario series, another RPG brand with kiddie appeal that adults nonetheless love as an alternative to meatier games.

If you're a fully grown human, though, a bit of Yo-Kai Watch's child-friendly elements can come off as a bit patronizing. Where Pokemon imagined a vast fantasy world where kids can leave school behind to tour the world with a pack of privately owned monsters, Yo-Kai's source material is a little more pedestrian. You're just a kid blessed with a magical device, tasked with solving the problems of others by destroying the evil spirits behind them. As a fan of Majora's Mask, I can't say I'm opposed to games about helping people, but, at times, Yo-Kai Watch seems a little too goody-goody. Many of the game's missions feel like they're also trying to teach children important life lessons that aren't particularly relevant to someone born during the Reagan administration: Go to bed on time, do your homework, don't gossip about others, look both ways before crossing the street, etc. If this game had a Dungeons & Dragons alignment, it'd definitely be "annoyingly lawful good."

Despite these minor issues, though, Yo-Kai Watch impressed me by how thoroughly it managed to keep my attention during the review process. And that's likely because it was designed to keep children engaged in an age of smart devices—which explains the sheer amount of things to do and rewards to be had around every corner. Pokemaniacs might crucify me for saying this, but Yo-Kai Watch really feels like the reinvention its predecessor needed years ago. True, I never play Pokemon for the high-level stuff, but then again, I'm guessing most people don't, either. And if Pokemon spoke to you long ago, but you can't muster up a reason to care anymore, Yo-Kai Watch is here to make you feel embarrassed about playing an addictive kids' RPG all over again.

The Nitty Gritty

  • Interface: The UI might look like it fell out of Candyland, but it makes for a breezy and efficient RPG experience.
  • Lasting appeal: There's a ton of things to do packed inside the dense world of Yo-Kai watch—especially for the brave few who aspire to "catch 'em all."
  • Sound: Appropriately cartoony and bouncy, with a distinct voice for each and every Yo-Kai.
  • Visuals: Level-5 has always done great things on small systems, and Yo-Kai Watch is no exception—this game looks fantastic.

Don't let Yo-Kai Watch's kiddie appeal fool you: It might not be as deep as your average, adult-style RPG, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Level-5's gradual evolution of their "house style" has amounted to a true successor to Pokemon—one entirely free of its predecessor's 8-bit baggage.

4 /5

Yo-Kai Watch 3DS Review: Borrowed Time Bob Mackey Level-5's monster-collecting RPG might not be wholly original, but it's perfect for lapsed Pokemon fans looking for a fresh take on a reliable formula. 2015-11-04T18:00:00-05:00 4 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 22

  • Avatar for ol\'dirty\'bus\'stop #1 ol\'dirty\'bus\'stop 2 years ago
    You said the magic words. I adored FF XIII's battle system.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jihon83 #2 jihon83 2 years ago
    This makes me wonder if the Simpsons' neon-clawed Gamblor is actually a Yo-kai.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vaporeon #3 Vaporeon 2 years ago
    Thanks for the great insight, Bob. The interface reminds me of that '90s game... was it Simon Says? Where you smash the colored areas around a circle? You know what's funny... most of these developers were probably '90s kids... ha! I wonder if they had that game in Japan...

    Anyway, can't wait for Friday.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kuni-Nino #4 Kuni-Nino 2 years ago
    > Pokemon sells 12 million copies with every new gen.

    > Bob says it needs a reinvention.

    Que? :P

    Anyways, good review. I think I understand why the series has captured the minds of so many kids in Japan. If I was ten years old, I'd probably care a lot more but I can't muster up any desire to do this sort of game again especially if they're going to simplify it even further. At least Pokemon gives you the opportunity to battle with your friends with one of the deepest turn-based combat systems around. I'll just hang on to my copy of Pokemon Y.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremyparish #5 jeremyparish 2 years ago
    @Vaporeon Did you just call Simon a '90s game!? Oh dear.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for bobservo #6 bobservo 2 years ago
    @Kuni-Nino And if sales equated quality and innovation, you might have a point.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for AlxndrNevermind #7 AlxndrNevermind 2 years ago
    This review reflects my feelings from playing the demo. I was so impressed with the world of Yo-Kai, how pretty the game is, and element of exploration in the game. Granted, the battle system is simple, but it probably has more nuance than it seems is there. One question Bob. Is there multiple save files? I would love to be able to share this game with my younger siblings.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vaporeon #8 Vaporeon 2 years ago
    @jeremyparish Ha! My bad then, Jeremy - I'll defer to your expertise. My only excuse is that my siblings span the '80s/'90s so I sometimes lump toys into the wrong decade. There are worse faults to have, right? :-)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for GaijinD #9 GaijinD 2 years ago
    @Vaporeon It's late '70s, actually, according to this reputable source:
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for bobservo #10 bobservo 2 years ago
    @GaijinD For me, people were trying to pass that abomination off as a "fun toy" as late as the mid-90s.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for daysofstatic65 #11 daysofstatic65 2 years ago
    I find myself consistently disappointed by Pokemon's overall lack of difficulty. Does Yo-Kai Watch offer much in terms of it?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for brionfoulke91 #12 brionfoulke91 2 years ago
    Sounds like a good game. Let's keep in mind that they could very easily have just carbon copied Pokemon's gameplay, and I bet there's a lot of AAA companies who would have done just that. But taking cues from FF13's massively underrated battle system is neat, and I like that they generally tried to do something a bit fresher. Gotta praise them for that, especially in this day and age.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for kbohls #13 kbohls 2 years ago
    Huh, I just ignorantly assumed this was a Pokémon ripoff with a battle system wholly designed for kids, but it actually sounds pretty neat. I will probably give the demo a whirl knowing that the battles get more interesting to see how I like the world, writing, and monster designs. Getting some Mega Man Battle Network vibes from the way the character explores the over world which is a pretty big plus in my book.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for ricklongo #14 ricklongo 2 years ago
    It's by Level-5. That's all I need to know to get it.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for naazimeaala75 #15 naazimeaala75 2 years ago
    A word on the story@Bob Mackay? Don't wanna buy a game where the plot is so paper thin that it becomes boring like I was in Dragon Quest Heroes!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for garion333 #16 garion333 2 years ago
    @daysofstatic65 No, it's a cake walk until you do a NewGame+ and even then...
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vaporeon #17 Vaporeon 2 years ago
    @garion333 How many hours would you say the game lasts, assuming you do most side-quests and collect most yo-kai? Sad to hear it's that easy, but I hope it's more enjoyable than slogging through the "Team" encounters in Pokemon.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Ghopper101 #18 Ghopper101 2 years ago
    This review has convinced me to take a closer look at this game. I might just pick this one up because it's different enough from Pokemon to offer something interesting.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for GaijinD #19 GaijinD 2 years ago
    @bobservo I've never liked it myself, but it's definitely had staying power.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for CipherStone #20 CipherStone 2 years ago
    As someone who felt pretty burnt out on Pokemon after X/Y, this game looks like a nice alternative. I may look into this after the holidays.

    Here's hoping the next Pokemon is more than just another coat of paint (but who am I kidding).
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mganai #21 mganai 2 years ago
    I always wished Pokemon had something more action based a la Paper Mario to emulate the anime battles a bit more, where counterattacks were a thing, for one.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for KobunX #22 KobunX 2 years ago
    I have been following this game's explosion in Japan and am quite ready to play it now.
    Sign in to Reply