Sections

The 10 Best Genesis/Mega Drive and Top 5 Sega CD Games

Sega's Genesis turns 25 today, and we're marking the occasion by celebrating the USgamer community's 10 favorite Genesis and top 5 Sega CD games.

Article by Jeremy Parish, .

Happy birthday to the Sega Genesis! 25 years ago today, Sega launched its 16-bit behemoth in Japan under the name Mega Drive, and the rest of the world followed over the next year or so.

But amidst reliving memories of console wars gone by -- as you argue about whether or not "blast processing" was cooler than "Mode 7" or whatever -- always remember that in the end, it's all about the games. And wow, did Sega Genesis have some great games. Don't take our word for it, though! Take your own.

We've compiled a list of the most beloved Sega Genesis games based on your feedback. Of course, the USgamer staff weighed in as well, but the following 10 Sega Genesis and five Sega CD games really represent your picks. Well, OK, it's more than 10 and five... there were a bunch of ties for the tenth and fifth spots on the lists, and rather than placing those games in some kind of grim retrospective deathmatch to determine the winner, we just included them all. After all, this is a celebration of games. The more, the merrier.

(And no, we didn't include 32X games. We couldn't think of five worth including.)

Not happy with your peers' picks? Cranky to see a personal favorite slighted? Let us know what should have made the cut!

Genesis

1. Gunstar Heroes
The easy winner, Sega's most beloved 16-bit game almost didn't see release in the U.S. -- and what a tragedy that would have been. Created by Treasure, a group of hyper-talented programmers and designers who got fed up making sequels to NES games, Gunstar Heroes set the high-water mark for Genesis technology. Each and every stage featured an insane gimmick that by all rights should have been impossible on the system, from a punch-up on the wings of a wildly tilting airplane to the infamous Seven Force, a running stage-long boss fight against a bizarre conglomerate creature that constantly changed shapes to challenge you with new battles. In one level, there's even a board game to master. Endlessly inventive, technically dazzling, and sophisticated like no one's business, Gunstar Heroes remains the gold standard for 2D action games.

2. Sonic the Hedgehog 2
Nipping at Gunstar Heroes' heels was the second and -- indisputably -- best Sonic the Hedgehog game, Sonic 2. The perfect balance of substance and simplicity, Sonic 2 expanded considerably on its predecessor's arcade action, but hadn't yet become so bogged down in extra features that it sacrificed the series' essential focus on momentum and movement. The asymmetrical multiplayer design wasn't just a technical tour-de-force (the split-screen presentation is really something to behold when both players are going full guns), it also gave younger siblings a way to join in the action without crimping their more capable older brother or sister's style. Colorful, challenging, and packed with countless secrets, Sonic 2 is still the game Sonic Team should be aiming to beat even after all these years.

3. Phantasy Star IV
The Genesis may not have been known for its role-playing games, but the handful that it offered stood on par with anything that Super NES fans enjoyed. Phantasy Star IV brought the long-running RPG series to a rousing finale, featuring callbacks to the story explored in the first two games but greatly toning down the awkward unfriendliness of Phantasy Star II's design. Meanwhile, its manga-style cutscenes helped bring the story to life in a way that wobbling sprites alone could never have accomplished. The game was impossibly pricey for its time, but as the dozens of fans who named it as a favorite in our poll can attest, it was worth every cent.

4. Streets of Rage 2
Final Fight may have been the 800-pound gorilla of arcade brawling games, but Sega humbled Capcom at home with the Streets of Rage series. Well, really, it was Streets of Rage 2 that set the standard; the first and third games had some serious shortcomings. But in between Sega absolutely nailed it. Cool characters, vivid and varied settings, killer moves, and amazing music that can only be described as "aural sex" -- Streets of Rage 2 remains the best reason to walk from left to right and punch endless armies of identical-looking goons.

5. Shining Force II
Camelot's Shining Force games, spun off from the old-school dungeon-crawler Shining in the Darkness, were basically just a big rip-off of Nintendo's Fire Emblem series. But Shining Force had two huge advantages: One, the presentation was miles better, with bold graphics and a framing setup reminiscent of a more traditional RPG. And two, the series didn't take 15 freaking years to leave Japan. While Nintendo-allied strategy buffs had to make do with staring at pictures of Fire Emblem and Tactics Ogre in the import sections of their favorite magazines, Sega fans enjoyed several Shining Force games... and of them all, the second was definitely the best, with an engrossing story to give welcome context to all those turn-based battles.

6. Shinobi III: Return of the Ninja Master
Living proof of the old maxim "delays are temporary, mediocrity is forever," Shinobi III left fans in the lurch for a year as Sega reworked the original version of the game to uphold the series' high standards. And they nailed it, too -- Joe Musashi's third adventure spanned a huge varieties of settings and formats, ranging from ancient Japan to bizarre futuristic sci-fi. But binding it all together were virtuosic visuals and a great soundtrack -- not to mention some fantastic boss designs.

7. Castlevania: Bloodlines
Perhaps the single most overlooked game in the entire Castlevania franchise, Bloodlines felt a bit like a throwback at the time, sticking more to the style of the NES games than of the more recent Super Castlevania IV and Rondo of Blood. But taken on those terms -- that is, a ripping arcade-style outing for the series -- it totally delivers. Sending players around the world to battle the undead in all sorts of famous locations, Bloodlines features two fairly different playable protagonists from the start and abandons the Belmont clan in an attempt to take the franchise into the modern era (and tie it in with Bram Stoker's Dracula). Solid fun, and don't forget the classic tunes (penned by composer Michiru Yamane in her Castlevania debut).

8. Sonic & Knuckles
I fudged a little bit on tallying this one, because votes were split between Sonic & Knuckles and Sonic 3 & Knuckles. But the great thing is, they're kind of the same game. Thanks to the gimmicky but cool "lock-on" cartridge concept, Sonic & Knuckles could attach to other Sonic carts and change up the experience. Admittedly, this worked best with Sonic 3 (since unlike the first two games it was designed with lock-on mods in mind), but nevertheless it's a creative enough concept to merit a mention simply for breathing new life into old, discarded games.

9. Phantasy Star II
While nowhere near as timeless as its more beloved sequel, the second chapter in the Phantasy Star series made quite an impression on American fans -- it arrived over here somewhere between the original Dragon Quest and the first Final Fantasy. By comparison, PSII felt absolutely massive... not to mention gloriously futuristic with its lavish cut scenes and intricate plot. Time has not treated its monotonous dungeons and sometimes inscrutable gameplay kindly, but in its day nothing could compare to PSII.

10. Toejam & Earl (tie)
Groovy, weird, esoteric: You can pull a lot of words at random from thin air and chances are pretty good they'll still describe Toejam & Earl. Kind of an action game, vaguely inspired by roguelike RPGs, offering cooperative action in the days when such things seemed curiously novel, TJ&E's quirkiness of play was matched only by the bizarreness of its style. Misshapen aliens wandered around surreal landscapes, fighting mundane enemies and gathering random treasures from gift boxes. Inexplicable, but loads of fun.

10. Beyond Oasis (tie)
If the Genesis had an answer to The Legend of Zelda, it was this gorgeous action-adventure game. Set in an Arabian Nights-inspired world and loaded with absolutely eye-popping artwork, Beyond Oasis felt a lot more no-frills than its direct competition on the Nintendo side of things, but that was no bad thing. Plus, Dytto was kind of like Navi years before there was a Navi, yet she managed to be infinitely cooler.

10. Monster World IV (tie)
Although it didn't come to the U.S. until very late (as in, last year), Monster World IV brought the Wonder Boy series to a rousing finale. Despite not actually starring Wonder Boy. A bold, colorful adventure with a smattering of exploration and spot-on controls, Monster World IV showed off the Genesis hardware at its best. If you haven't downloaded it for PS3 or Xbox 360 yet, you should do so immediately to avoid being cast out of your community as a pariah.

Sega CD

1. Snatcher
Back when he was allowed to work on games not called "Metal Gear," Hideo Kojima spent some time exploring the world of graphical adventures. Of his two projects, only Snatcher made its way overseas... and unfortunately, it was only produced for Sega CD, which means tiny quantities and high demand have pushed the aftermarket price of this classic into the stratosphere. But it's kind of worth it, as you can see Kojima's predilection for borrowing from Hollywood and his fondness for making clever use of the nature of video games all in one grand adventure that comes about as close as possible to being Blade Runner without Ridley Scott tapping you angrily on the shoulder.

2. Sonic CD
Yes, there's another Sonic game on this list. What I say? Kids love their Sonic. And this adventure in particular felt wonderfully ambitious, sending Sonic hurtling backward and forward in time to affect the nature and appearance of each stage. Although there used to be some degree of controversy over the soundtrack -- it was given a "butt rock" makeover for the U.S. -- I think by and large the consensus is to get the hell over it and just enjoy the game.

3. Lunar: The Silver Star & Lunar: Eternal Blue
These two actually placed consecutively on the list in third and fourth place, but whatever. Both games represent parts of a whole: A quaint role-playing adventure with a strong emphasis on characters followed by a sequel that explored the ramifications of the first game's outcome. Not only did the Lunar series add some serious RPG credibility to Sega's lineup, it also gave publisher Working Designs a major breakthrough, catching fans' attention with its witty localization methodology and lavish packaging.

4. Popful Mail
Another winner from Working Designs, Popful Mail is an exploratory action RPG in the Zelda II vein with a decidedly humorous vibe. In fact, this is the company's crowning achievement on Sega CD: They added a punchy script that made a slightly wacky tale downright hilarious. (It certainly didn't hurt that the underlying adventure was quite excellent to begin with.)

5. Keio Flying Squadron
This whimsical shooter flew under the radar for years, only really catching wide notice after its sequel (a platformer for Sega Saturn) failed to make its way to the U.S. One of the rarer and more expensive titles for Sega CD, Keio Flying Squadron concerns the adventures of a young girl named Rami, who lives in a non-existent period of Japanese history and fights evil creatures of folklore while riding a baby dragon and wearing a Playboy bunny outfit. Look, OK, it's weird... but it's really good, honest.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 22

  • Avatar for TPaulBuzan #1 TPaulBuzan 3 years ago
    I'm not trying to be "that guy" ... but not a single shmup on this list?! For shame, USGamer! For shame. With titles like M.U.S.H.A., Truxton, the Thunder Force series, and Fire Shark -- just to name a few off the top of my head -- representing the best of what the genre has to offer, no "best of" Genesis list is complete without at least a shmup or two on it.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for ArugulaZ #2 ArugulaZ 3 years ago
    @TPaulBuzan You know what Genesis game I think doesn't get the respect it deserves? Biohazard Battle. It's got smooth gameplay, freakishly cool artwork, and a power up system that offers plenty of variety while never leaving you helpless.

    Having said that, I was quite fond of Fire Shark as well. It was generic, but an otherwise excellent shooter in that Raiden bomb-bomb-bomb-die vein. I'd also like to add Sagaia and Space Invaders '91 as two of my personal Genesis favorites.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for lunarlasso #3 lunarlasso 3 years ago
    Man! I remember when my brother and I got Sonic the Hedgehog. Popped in the cart and that,"SEEEGAAAA" intro voice came over the TV. We looked at each other and just said, "Daaaaaang". We couldn't believe it just talked to us. That speed of sonic killed mario's slow deliberate pace. Oh, and when you would teeter next to an edge or not do anything with the controller, Man those where great animations! Then Lakers vs Celtics. First simulation basketball game we had ever played. All those NBA signature moves. Even Tom Chambers had his own dunk! It was NBA Live before NBA Live. Ah, man. The good ole days.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for TPaulBuzan #4 TPaulBuzan 3 years ago
    @ArugulaZ, I agree completely. Biohazard Battle is definitely one of the Genesis's forgotten gems. I must have rented that game 15 times from my local video store back in the day.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Genocidal #5 Genocidal 3 years ago
    Any chance you can post the full list of votes? The local game store is downsizing Genesis and I'd love to see what others think is worth playing.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Zero-Crescent #6 Zero-Crescent 3 years ago
    Hmmm, a Top 5 of 32X games... Sounds like a challenge!
    1. Virtua Racing Deluxe
    2. Knuckles Chaotix
    3. Virtua Fighter
    4. Afterburner Complete
    5. Kolibri
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Funny_Colour_Blue #7 Funny_Colour_Blue 3 years ago
    @Zero-Crescent I liked BC Racers...just because it's BC RACERS!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for metalangel #8 metalangel 3 years ago
    I love my Sega CD. Unfortunately, near the end a lot of the very best games were almost impossible to find and I actually have dreams where I go into a used game store and find Keio Flying Squadron and Popful Mail, among others. I am extremely fortunate to own Snatcher!

    Some runners-up:
    -Wing Commander. Potentially the definitive version, in that it offers full speech to bring the epic storyline to life.
    -Third World War. A combination strategy/almost-RTS, very absorbing.
    -The Terminator. The definitive, again, game of the first movie. Eight ridiculously huge levels, Tommy Tallarico soundtrack, gorgeous fluid animation.
    -AH3 Thunderstrike. Desert Strike (where was that on your list?) from a first person perspective, basically.

    It was an awesome system but unfortunately the obsession with FMV at the time spoiled it, especially considering how terrible unoptimized FMV looked on the Sega CD. Later titles like Tomcat Alley managed to make it full screen and less grainy but 'interactive movies' were always going to be a dead end.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for DiscordInc #9 DiscordInc 3 years ago
    Nice list. I've always felt that Sonic 2 was the best of the original series and it's good to see it get a shout out.

    Speaking of shout outs, one game that didn't appear on the list but definitely deserves an honorable mention is Rocket Knight Adventures. On the surface it looks like a mascot platformer on a platform that was glutted with them, but it plays like a vintage Konami action game. It reminds me a lot of Gunstar Heroes in that just when you think the game has reached its craziest point, it finds another way to take it even higher. Definitely worth playing through if you overlooked it in the past.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for alexb #10 alexb 3 years ago
    Man, that's a pretty solid list. I can't really disagree with it, which almost never happens with this "Top X Games of Y" things. The nice, high resolution header graphic was also appreciated. Sometimes those things are pretty low res and grody looking, but this one sings.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for orient #11 orient 3 years ago
    I'm also of the opinion that Sonic 2 is the best Sonic game, and not just on the Mega Drive, but of all time. I always found that the levels in Sonic 3/Knuckles didn't flow as well. The power-ups felt tacked on and the music wasn't as good (apart from the boss music, which is incredible).

    Snatcher is a fantastic game, too. One of my all-time favourite adventure games. Superb art and music.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Captain-Gonru #12 Captain-Gonru 3 years ago
    @metalangel Good call on Wing Commander. Also from the licensed game vault would be Star Wars Arcade.
    Plus, I remember a few point-and-click adventure games on Sega CD. I gotta dig that thing out again...
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for metalangel #13 metalangel 3 years ago
    @Captain Gonru: Star Wars Arcade (the 32X one, right?) wasn't that great, not to anyone who'd played one of the X-Wing games.

    The only point and click adventure I actually own is the Jurassic Park one which is fairly decent. However, I rented a lot of the others like Iron Helix, Monkey Island (awful port, very very stiff and slow), Mansion of Hidden Souls. I'm not sure if it'll count, but the version of Dune was pretty amazing too. The music got a separate release and, again, it was entirely voice acted.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for brionfoulke91 #14 brionfoulke91 3 years ago
    Monster World IV is such a fantastic game, great to see it on this list! Not a lot of people have played it and more really should! It's available on PSN.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SargeSmash #15 SargeSmash 3 years ago
    This list is incredibly solid. (Jeremy even let me write about some of these for GameSpite, despite my distinct lack of experience!)

    Monster World IV deserves to be played by everyone. It's a wonderful game, and I've now played through the game three times over the years with the unofficial fan translation. Now that there is an official release, I'll probably go through it there, too!

    Another game I thought of is Ristar. Almost a perfect combination of Sonic-like aesthetics and Bionic Commando-ish gameplay. So much fun, absolutely stunning to look at, and criminally overlooked in the waning years of the Genesis.

    Popful Mail was one of those games that was so funny, I'd be sure to go into every talking bit with each character to hear their lines. Sven T. Uncommon was particularly uproarious. :)

    I do have to cop to the fact that I didn't really like Sonic CD all that much... but maybe that owes to me playing it on the PC, or just not liking Sonic as much as Mario or other platformers. I do have to admit that Sonic 2 is probably the best of the bunch, although I can see some strong design chops in the original as well. Add a spin dash to that, and it'd be perfect. (Actually, didn't a phone version or something add that feature?)

    Great writeup!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Zero-Crescent #16 Zero-Crescent 3 years ago
    @metalangel Heh, in Wing Commander CD, your mission briefer is voiced by Cam Clarke. It's pretty funny to hear Liquid Snake giving you flight orders.

    Anyways, a few more honorable mentions for the CD:
    - Eternal Champions: Challenge from the Dark Side
    The definitive edition of Eternal Champions, with CD audio and a bunch of new (and unlockable!) characters. They even had a hidden Joe Lieberman parody character.

    - Final Fight CD
    An excellent Redbook audio soundtrack, all three characters available, and an added time attack mode makes this one of the better ports of Final Fight out there.

    - Ecco the Dolphin CD
    It's a mostly a port of Ecco, but with extra levels and an awesome Redbook audio soundtrack, it's the definitive version.

    - Shining Force CD
    A remake/semi-sequel/compilation of the two Game Gear games, enhanced with the Genesis engine. Lots of classic SF gameplay backed by an excellent Redbook audio soundtrack.

    - Heart of the Alien: Out of this World 1 & 2
    Probably the best version of OotW until the Anniversary edition. This also includes the Sega CD-exclusive non-canon sequel, which... isn't anywhere as good as the original. But since it includes the original, with an upgraded Redbook soundtrack, it's still worth your time.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for metalangel #17 metalangel 3 years ago
    @Zero-Crescent: If you like Heart of the Alien, you have to go read the FAQ for it on GameFAQs by SkedarJanitor. The whole non-canon factor is taken to an extreme with discussion of the controversial ending taking up more of the FAQ than the walkthrough.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for tyetheczar #18 tyetheczar 3 years ago
    If you're willing to get your hands dirty with a translation patch, the Japanese version of Streets of Rage 3, Bare Knuckle III is actually better - except for the music. The US version ramped the difficulty up to unfair and omitted some enemies.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SargeSmash #19 SargeSmash 3 years ago
    @tyetheczar : Yeah, I played through it there a while back, and it's a lot more fun when the game is a bit more fair, like its predecessor. The music _is_ terrible, though.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for ottowaragon55 #20 ottowaragon55 2 years ago
    Final Fight CD?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for aminehdd85 #21 aminehdd85 2 years ago
    flashback !!!??
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for kearnesolanke82 #22 kearnesolanke82 A year ago
    im not trying to be rude at the guy who made this list but i think the sonic game's he but up there should be first
    Sign in to Reply

Comments

Close